Divine governance of the human kingdom
التدبيرات الإلهية في إصلاح المملكة الإنسانية
al-Tadbīrāt al-ilāhiyya fī iṣlāḥ al-mamlaka al-insāniyya
Ibn ʿArabī (560–638/1165–1240)
Ibn ʿArabī · Counsel and governance · Arabic · 6th century AH · Listed only
Counsel on governing the human being as a kingdom under the intellect. Its preface sets it against the Sirr al-asrār's governance of the worldly kingdom, and addresses both the servant of kings and the traveller on the path.
- Attribution
- authentic: The text opens in his own name, 'Muḥammad b. ʿAlī al-ʿArabī al-Ḥātimī al-Ṭāʾī' (Nyberg, first text page, unnumbered), and speaks in the first person of its composition (pp. 120–121). Yahia 1964, the specialist reference, is not yet in hand. ✓ checked in H. S. Nyberg (ed.), Kleinere Schriften des Ibn al-ʿArabī (Leiden: Brill, 1919); the Tadbīrāt is printed in the Arabic section, text pp. 103–240 (see LEDGER)
- Date
- Composed at Mawrūr (Morón) 'in under four days' (dūn al-arbaʿa al-ayyām, Nyberg p. 121); the year is not yet established (draft: before 598/1202), Mawrūr (Morón), al-Andalus (basis: date of composition) probable
- Editions
- H. S. Nyberg (ed.), Kleinere Schriften des Ibn al-ʿArabī (Leiden: Brill, 1919), Arabic text of the Tadbīrāt pp. 103–240 (title page unnumbered; p. 240 ends 'tamma al-kitāb'), with sigla B1, B2, B3, U · public domain ✓ checked in H. S. Nyberg (ed.), Kleinere Schriften des Ibn al-ʿArabī (Leiden: Brill, 1919); the Tadbīrāt is printed in the Arabic section, text pp. 103–240 (see LEDGER)
- Critical Arabic edition with Urdu, Abrar Ahmed Shahi (Ibn al-Arabi Foundation, 2020, 3rd ed.) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Tosun Bayrak al-Jerrahi, Divine Governance of the Human Kingdom (Fons Vitae, 1997), reported by the draft as made from Ottoman Turkish; unchecked · en · cite only not yet checked
Connected works
- Resonance, not influence: Opinions of the people of the virtuous city The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
- Resonance, not influence: Epistles of the Brethren of Purity; The Case of the Animals versus Man before the King of the Jinn The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
- Resonance, not influence: The refinement of character The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
- Lineage: The Secret of Secrets The preface names it (Nyberg pp. 120–121, read from the page images). At Mawrūr, with Abū Muḥammad al-Mawrūrī, Ibn ʿArabī found the 'Kitāb Sirr al-asrār', which 'the sage' (al-ḥakīm) composed for Dhū l-Qarnayn; he was asked to set against it the governance of the human kingdom, 'in which is our happiness'. He says he put into his book more on governing a kingdom than the sage did and made clear what the sage left out, and that the sage's book is a quarter or a third of its size. He names the author only as 'the sage' and the king as Dhū l-Qarnayn; the title identifies the book. Confidence: high. ✓ checked in H. S. Nyberg (ed.), Kleinere Schriften des Ibn al-ʿArabī (Leiden: Brill, 1919); the Tadbīrāt is printed in the Arabic section, text pp. 103–240 (see LEDGER)
- Resonance, not influence: Republic Both treat the ruled soul as a polity under reason. No source seen documents a route from the Republic to the Tadbīrāt; the Tadbīrāt's preface names the Sirr al-asrār, not the Republic or al-Fārābī. Confidence: low. probable
Four Discourses
چهار مقاله
Chahār maqāla
Niẓāmī ʿArūḍī (fl. c. 551/1156)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Persian · 6th century AH · Listed only
Discusses the secretary, poet, astrologer and physician: those needed by the king.
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1156, Samarkand/Herat (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- E. G. Browne (London 1910, text) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- E. G. Browne (1899; rev. 1921) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
The Walled Garden of Truth
حدیقة الحقیقة
Ḥadīqat al-ḥaqīqa
Sanāʾī (d. c. 525/1131)
Sufism · The path · Persian · 6th century AH · Listed only
Mathnawī with sections on kings and justice, mixed with mystic teaching.
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1131, Ghazna (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Modarres Razavi (Tehran 1329 sh) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- David Pendlebury (The Walled Garden of Truth, London 1974) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Commentary on Plato's Republic
جوامع سياسة أفلاطون
Jawāmiʿ siyāsat Aflāṭūn
Ibn Rushd (Averroes) (1126–1198)
Philosophy · Counsel and governance · Arabic · 6th century AH · Listed only
Ibn Rushd's commentary on Plato's Republic, kept in Hebrew; it takes the Republic as the political philosophy he lacked in Aristotle's Politics.
- Attribution
- authentic: SEP: he wrote a commentary on Plato's Republic and begins it by saying he will abstract the demonstrative arguments and remove the dialectical ones. ✓ checked in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Ibn Rushd [Averroes]”
- Date
- c. 1194 (draft; unchecked) (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- E. I. J. Rosenthal (ed. and tr.), Averroes' Commentary on Plato's Republic (Cambridge UP, 1956): the Hebrew text with English translation; the Arabic original is lost · cite only probable
- Translations
- Ralph Lerner, Averroes on Plato's Republic (Cornell UP, 1974) · en · cite only probable
- Rosenthal 1956 (with the Hebrew text) · en · cite only probable
Not in the reader yet
Connected works
- Resonance, not influence: Opinions of the people of the virtuous city The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
- Lineage: Republic It is a commentary on the Republic (SEP, which also notes that its brevity does not show deep knowledge of the whole text). Confidence: high. ✓ checked in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Ibn Rushd [Averroes]”; Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “al-Farabi”
Persian Kalīla and Dimna
کلیله و دمنه (Naṣrallāh Munshī)
Kalīla va Dimna
Naṣrallāh Munshī (fl. c. 538/1144)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Persian · 6th century AH · Listed only
Persian rendering of Kalīla with embellishments;
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1144, Ghazna (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Mojtabā Mīnuvī (Tehran 1343 sh) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
The Conference of the Birds
منطق الطیر
Manṭiq al-ṭayr
Farīd al-Dīn ʿAṭṭār (d. c. 618/1221)
Sufism · The path · Persian · 6th century AH · Listed only
Birds seek the Simurgh, their king;
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1177, Nishapur (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Gowharin (Tehran 1342 sh) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Darbandi and Davis (Penguin 1984) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Connected works
- Resonance, not influence: Spiritual Couplets The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
Counsel for Kings (Book of Counsel for Kings)
نصیحة الملوک
Naṣīḥat al-mulūk
al-Ghazālī (450–505/1058–1111)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Persian · 6th century AH · Listed only
Faith as foundation of kingship;
- Attribution
- disputed: The draft says the first half may be his and the second part from another hand. TDV treats it as al-Ghazālī's, written in Baghdad under the Seljuks. The scope doc names Patricia Crone, 'Did al-Ghazālī write a mirror for princes?', JSAI 10 (1987): title and year 1987 seen in OpenAlex; the argument has not been read. probable
- Date
- c. 1105-09, Tus / Baghdad (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Jalāl al-Dīn Humāʾī (Tehran 1315 sh/1937) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- F. R. C. Bagley, Ghazali's Book of Counsel for Kings (OUP 1964) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Statesman's Book
Policraticus
Policraticus
John of Salisbury (d. 1180)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Latin · 6th century AH · Listed only
The commonwealth as body: prince as head, priests as soul, army as hands;
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- 1159, Canterbury/Chartres (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Webb (Oxford 1909); Nederman CUP tr. (1990) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Cary Nederman (CUP 1990); Pike (1938) 'Frivolities of Courtiers' · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Secret of Secrets (Latin versions)
Secretum secretorum (Latin)
Secretum secretorum
John of Seville and Philip of Tripoli (Latin translators) (12th–13th c. CE)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Latin · 6th century AH · Listed only
Two Latin translations carried the work to Europe, where it became one of the most copied 'Aristotelian' texts (hundreds of manuscripts).
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- 12th-13th c., Toledo/Spain; Tripoli/Antioch (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- R. Steele, Opera hactenus inedita Rogeri Baconi, fasc. V (Oxford 1920) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Steven J. Williams, The Secret of Secrets (Ann Arbor 2003) discusses translations · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Connected works
- Resonance, not influence: The Secret of Secrets The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
The Lamp of Kings
سراج الملوك
Sirāj al-mulūk
al-Ṭurṭūshī (d. 520/1126)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Arabic · 6th century AH · Listed only
A learned jurist's mirror: kingship as divine trust, with long stories of Persian kings and Prophetic ḥadīth;
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1122, Alexandria (Fatimid vizier al-Maʾmūn al-Baṭāʾiḥī) (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Būlāq 1872; Jaʿfar al-Bayātī (London 1990) · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Maurice Alarcón, Lámpara de los príncipes (Madrid 1930-31) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Solace for the Ruler during Hostility of Subjects (Waters of Comfort)
سلوان المطاع في عدوان الأتباع
Sulwān al-muṭāʿ fī ʿudwān al-atbāʿ
Ibn Ẓafar al-Ṣiqillī (d. c. 565/1170)
Further afield · Counsel and governance · Arabic · 6th century AH · Listed only
Stories and parables on how rulers and subjects weather misfortune, with consolation from Providence;
- Attribution
- authentic not yet checked
- Date
- c. 1159-60, Sicily, then Hama (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- Beirut 1995; Tunis 1279/1862; Istanbul 1285/1868 · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
- Translations
- Michele Amari, Italian (Florence 1851) and Solwan; or Waters of Comfort (London 1852) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Regime (Rule) of the solitary
تدبير المتوحد
Tadbīr al-mutawaḥḥid
Ibn Bājja (Avempace) (c. 1085–1139)
Philosophy · Counsel and governance · Arabic · 6th century AH · Listed only
In an imperfect city the philosopher must govern himself alone and perfect his intellect by himself: the political question turns inward.
- Attribution
- authentic: SEP gives it as his Tadbīr al-mutawaḥḥid, with Asín Palacios's edition and Spanish translation and Dunlop's 1945 article. ✓ checked in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Ibn Bajja [Avempace]”
- Date
- early 12th c., Saragossa, Fez (basis: date of composition) not yet checked
- Editions
- M. Asín Palacios (ed. and Spanish tr.), El régimen del solitario (Madrid, 1946), as cited in the SEP bibliography · cite only ✓ checked in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Ibn Bajja [Avempace]”
- Translations
- Lawrence Berman in Lerner and Mahdi (1963) · en · cite only (unchecked) not yet checked
Not in the reader yet
Connected works
- Resonance, not influence: Opinions of the people of the virtuous city The first draft claims influence; not yet checked. not yet checked
- Lineage: Republic SEP: Avempace reads and quotes Plato, and turns the analogy the other way: the Republic takes the soul as the model of the city, he starts from the ideal city and carries its order into the solitary soul. A documented reading, with the direction reversed. Confidence: high. ✓ checked in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Ibn Bajja [Avempace]”