Root · 154 in the Quran · 590 in 27 texts of the library
غيرIbn Fāris gives two sound roots: setting right, benefit and provisioning, under which he … (root ghyr)
الغين والياء والراء أصلان صحيحان يدل أحدهما على صلاح وإصلاح ومنفعة والآخر على اختلاف شيئين
Ibn Fāris, Maqāyīs al-lugha · English rendering AI
The family of the root
Patterns computed · our dataThe words of غ ي ر that our sources attest: the root's letters in green, the added letters in gold.
30 words7 verbs7 verbal nouns3 participles3 places and instruments4 intensives and elatives3 other nouns2 plurals1 relative or abstract
- غَيْرit qualifies an indeterminate noun
- تَغَيَّرَit became other than it was
- تَغَيُّرtransformation; change
- غَيَّرَhe made the thing other than it was
- غَيْرَةjealousy
The whole family8 groups, by pattern; tap a pattern to see what it does
Verbs7غَارَ · تَغَيَّرَ · غَيَّرَ
The root as an action: the bare Form I, and the Forms made by adding letters before, inside or after the root.grammar →
- غَارَForm ILane
- تَغَيَّرَit became other than it wasLaneForm VQurʾān ×1library ×13Lane
- غَيَّرَhe made the thing other than it wasLaneForm IIQurʾān ×4library ×1LaneIbn Fāris
- غايَرَbetween them two is a differenceLaneForm IIIlibrary ×1Lane
Verbal nouns7غَيْر · تَغَيُّر · غَيْرَة
The action itself, named as a noun (maṣdar).grammar →
- غَيْرit qualifies an indeterminate nounLaneForm I · Lane: inf. n.Qurʾān ×147library ×335LaneIbn Fāris
- تَغَيُّرtransformation; changeautoForm Vlibrary ×11
- غَيْرَةjealousyLaneForm I · Lane: inf. n.library ×5LaneIbn Fāris
- تَغْيِيرchange; modificationautoForm II · Lane: inf. n.library ×3Lane
Participles3مُغَيِّر · مُغايِر · مُتَغَيِّر
The one who does it, and the one it is done to.grammar →
- مُغَيِّرone who puts down the furniture of his camel from off him, to relieve and …Laneactive, Form IIQurʾān ×1Lane
- مُغايِرactive, Form IIIlibrary ×2
- مُتَغَيِّرchanging; alternatingautoactive, Form Vlibrary ×1
Place, time and instrument3مَغار · مَغِيرَة · مِغْيَار
Where or when it happens, and what it is done with: the m- nouns.grammar →
- مَغارcave; cavernautonoun of place or timelibrary ×2
- مَغِيرَةland wateredLanenoun of place (with -a)Lane
- مِغْيَارnoun of instrumentLane
Intensives, qualities and the elative4غَيُور · أَغْيَر · غَيَّار
The quality carried far, held as a trait, or compared.grammar →
- غَيُورjealousautointensive (faʿūl)library ×1Lane
- أَغْيَرmore jealous than feverLaneelative or colour adjective (afʿal)Lane
- غَيَّارintensive (faʿʿāl)Lane
- غَيْرَانintensive (faʿlān)Lane
Other nouns3غِيرَة · غِيَر · مَغْيُورَة
Nouns on other patterns; their meaning is learned word by word.grammar →
Plurals2غِيَر · مُغِيرَات
Broken plurals rebuild the word on a new pattern; sound plurals add an ending.grammar →
Relative and abstract1غَيْرِيّ
-iyy relates a thing to its source; -iyya makes an abstract noun.grammar →
- غَيْرِيّaltruistautorelative adjective (-iyy)library ×4
Reference
Why this shape?What each of the 21 patterns does
What each pattern does. The pattern gives a tendency, not a rule: many words have drifted into meanings of their own.
The pattern machinePour the root into a pattern; see whether the word exists
Choose a pattern; the root's letters pour into it. Then see whether the word exists in our sources. The machine makes shapes; only usage makes words.
- Attested: مَغِيرَة, noun of place (with -a), “land watered” (Lane)
Place noun with -a. The place noun with the feminine -a. Sometimes it is only a variant of mafʿal; often it names the place where a thing is found in abundance (maʾsada, 'a place full of lions'). So maktab is the place of writing, and maktaba, where writings are gathered: a library, a bookshop. Our summary AI
But: maktaba is not in our classical dictionaries for k-t-b: Lane and al-Jawharī give maktab ('a school'), none gives maktaba. Its sense of 'library, bookshop' fits the pattern of abundance, but that is our reading of the pattern, not a classical entry. Many mafʿala words are single items of usage (maqbara 'cemetery'), which the grammarians call heard, not formed by rule.
The grammarians on this pattern (4)
ما يكون مفعلة لازمة لها الهاء والفتحة … وذلك إذا أردت أن تكثر الشيء بالمكان، وذلك قولك: أرض مسبعة، ومأسدة
Chapter on what is mafʿala, with the -a and the a-vowel always: that is when you mean that a thing abounds in a place, as you say 'a land of many beasts of prey (masbaʿa), of many lions (maʾsada)' AI
Sībawayh (d. c. 180/796), al-Kitāb, ed. ʿAbd al-Salām Hārūn, 3rd ed. (Cairo: al-Khānjī, 1988), 4:94 · OpenITI line 21027–21028 ↗ · on this site · OpenITI RELEASE v2025.1.9, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
و نحو المظنة و المقبرة فتحا و ضما ليس بقياس
and words like maẓinna and maqbara (with a or u) are not by rule AI
Ibn al-Ḥājib (d. 646/1249), al-Shāfiya fī ʿilm al-taṣrīf, ed. Ḥasan Aḥmad al-ʿUthmān (Mecca: al-Maktaba al-Makkiyya, 1995), 1:30 · OpenITI line 223 ↗ · on this site · OpenITI RELEASE v2025.1.9, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
- “designate the place where the object signified by the noun from which they are formed, is found in large numbers or quantities” Wright, Grammar I, §247, p. 148 ↗ · on nouns of abundance, maf'ala · 3rd ed. (Cambridge, 1896) · public domain
- “Nouns of time and place not unfrequently take the feminine form” Wright, Grammar I, §225, p. 128 ↗ · on maf'ala as a variant of maf'al · 3rd ed. (Cambridge, 1896) · public domain
This root has a weak or doubled letter, so real words change shape (qāla → qāʾil, not qāwil); the machine pours the letters in as they are, and matches attested words by their regular pattern.
About thisWhat “attested” means here; the sources
Attested means found in our data: the Quranic Arabic Corpus (lemmas, verb Forms, participles, verbal nouns, plurals), the library's words (automatic analysis), Lane's Lexicon (his headwords, the Forms he numbers, the verbal nouns and plurals he names) and Ibn Fāris's entry. Nothing is generated for this list. Meanings are Lane's first gloss in his entry, or else the analyser's gloss (“auto”). Vowelling follows the corpus, then Lane, then the analyser; verbs are given in the regular perfect. Lane's Lexicon thins out after qāf, and a few of his entries cover several roots at once: those roots show no Lane. The patterns, written with ف ع ل, are computed by us.
The dictionaries
English: AI translation AIal-Jawharī · 393الغيرة بالكسر: الميرة.
al-Jawharī (d. c. 393/1003), al-Ṣiḥāḥ. Admits only usage he judged sound.
Ibn Fāris · 395Ghayn, yāʾ, and rāʾ (غ ي ر) have two sound roots: one indicates soundness/reform and benefit, and the other indicates the difference between two things.
Ibn Fāris (d. 395/1004), Maqāyīs al-Lugha. Seeks each root's original sense (aṣl).
AI AI translation of the Arabic belowal-Rāghib · 502غير يقال على أوجه: الأول: أن تكون للنفي المجرد من غير إثبات معنى به، نحو: مررت برجل غير قائم.
al-Rāghib al-Iṣfahānī (d. c. 502/1108), al-Mufradāt. Quranic vocabulary, from core sense to Quranic usage.
Lisān · 711التهذيب: غير من حروف المعاني، تكون نعتا وتكون بمعنى لا، وله باب على حدة.
Ibn Manẓūr (d. 711/1311), Lisān al-ʿArab. The great compendium of the earlier dictionaries (entry shortened).
Lane · 1876English, synthesising the classical dictionaries.
E. W. Lane (d. 1876), An Arabic-English Lexicon. English, synthesising the classical dictionaries.
Lane, Arabic-English Lexiconread Lane's entry online ↗
The same letters, turned
The same three letters in all six orders. Choose one.
غ ي ر
الغين والياء والراء أصلان صحيحان يدل أحدهما على صلاح وإصلاح ومنفعة والآخر على اختلاف شيئين
Gh-y-r has two sound roots: one indicates soundness, improvement, and benefit, and the other indicates the difference between two things. AI
an entry in Ibn Fārislater sources onlyin none of them
Do these six share one core meaning?
Reference
About thisal-Khalīl, Ibn Jinnī, Ibn Fāris; the counts across the dictionary
al-Khalīl (d. c. 170/786), Kitāb al-ʿAyn, as transmitted by al-Layth: a two-letter word “turns in two ways”, a three-letter word “in six ways” (masdūsa), four letters in 24, five in 120; “its used forms are written down and its unused ones dropped” (line 975 ↗). The dictionary is built on this: each chapter takes a set of letters and names which orders are used (mustaʿmal) and which unused (muhmal). The ring shows that verdict, from the chapter heading as edited (documented in the text; how much of the book is al-Khalīl's own is disputed).
A reported total. al-Suyūṭī transmits, from Ḥamza al-Iṣfahānī, that al-Khalīl put the possible forms, used and unused, of two to five letters at 12,305,412 (al-Muzhir, line 1347 ↗). It is reported, not found in the ʿAyn. It equals exactly the arrangements of 2 to 5 different letters out of 28 (756 + 19,656 + 491,400 + 11,793,600); the breakdown printed beside it is corrupt, and al-Zubaydī's count, given next, differs (6,659,400).
Ibn Jinnī (d. 392/1002), al-Khaṣāʾiṣ, names the greater derivation (al-ishtiqāq al-akbar): bind a three-letter root and its six orders to one meaning, and bring stray members back “by the subtlety of the craft and interpretation” (line 7536 ↗). He says himself that it does not hold for every root (line 167 ↗; line 7603 ↗).
Ibn Fāris (d. 395/1004) gives each root its own aṣl and treats a rearranged word as maqlūb, “turned round”, and so not a root of its own: “j-b-dh is not a root, because it is a single word, turned round” (Maqāyīs, line 6147 ↗). The ring sets his aṣl for each order side by side; whether they meet is the question.
Neighbours on the ring differ by one swap of two letters.
The critique. A source quoted by al-Suyūṭī calls the greater derivation Ibn Jinnī's innovation, “not relied on in the language” (al-Muzhir, line 6159 ↗).
The other axis. The root's letters also go into patterns that keep their order and change the frame: the patterns (awzān) and the verb Forms I–X.
Across Ibn Fāris's dictionary. Of the 2,300 possible sets of three different sound letters (no hamza, w or y), 1,021 have at least one order as an entry. How many of their six orders are entries:
- 1 of 6319
- 2 of 6218
- 3 of 6164
- 4 of 6155
- 5 of 6107
- 6 of 658
- 1 of 6148
- 2 of 6108
- 3 of 6157
- 4 of 6179
- 5 of 6111
- 6 of 643
Of the orders al-Khalīl calls used, 2,097 are entries in Ibn Fāris and 267 are not; 17 that he calls unused are entries in Ibn Fāris.
Attested here means found in our digital texts (Ibn Fāris, Lisān al-ʿArab, Lane, the Quranic Arabic Corpus), with w and y kept apart and hamza spellings merged; it is our data, not a classical verdict. English beside the Arabic is AI translation. Sources and grades: docs/research/root-permutations.md.
Letters & sound
- غghayntop of the throat · voiced, continuantSīb. · I. Jinnī
- يyāʾmiddle of the tongue · voiced, in betweenSīb. · I. Jinnī
- رrāʾtip of the tongue, near the nūn · voiced, in betweenSīb. · I. Jinnī
How each letter is made, in brief, from Sībawayh's and Ibn Jinnī's own sentences (linked); their words are under Reference.
Sharing two of its three letters (computed; kinship of form, not of meaning)
Reference
How it is madeSībawayh and Ibn Jinnī · phonetics
English throughout: AI translation of the Arabic AI
غ
وأدناها مخرجا من الفم: الغين والخاء
The nearest of them to the mouth in place: the ghayn and the khāʾ. Sībawayh, line 26549 ↗
ومما فوق ذلك مع أول الفم، مخرج الغين والخاء
From above that, at the start of the mouth, is the place of the ghayn and the khāʾ. Ibn Jinnī, line 971 ↗
ي
ومن وسط اللسان بينه وبين وسط الحنك الأعلى مخرج الجيم والشين والياء
From the middle of the tongue, between it and the middle of the upper palate, is the place of the jīm, the shīn and the yāʾ. Sībawayh, line 26553 ↗
ومن وسط اللسان بينه وبين وسط الحنك الأعلى، مخرج الجيم والشين والياء
From the middle of the tongue, between it and the middle of the upper palate, is the place of the jīm, the shīn and the yāʾ. Ibn Jinnī, line 974 ↗
ر
ومن مخرج النون غير أنه أدخل في ظهر اللسان قليلا لانحرافه إلى اللام مخرج الراء
From the place of the nūn, except that it goes a little further onto the back of the tongue, because it leans towards the lām, is the place of the rāʾ. Sībawayh, lines 26557–26558 ↗
ومن مخرج النون غير أنه أدخل في ظهر اللسان قليلا، لانحرافه إلى اللام، مخرج الراء
From the place of the nūn, except that it goes a little further onto the back of the tongue, because it leans towards the lām, is the place of the rāʾ. Ibn Jinnī, lines 980–981 ↗
Sībawayh, al-Kitāb (ed. Hārūn) and Ibn Jinnī, Sirr ṣināʿat al-iʿrāb; OpenITI digital texts (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). Full credits on each letter's page.
In the Breath of the All-MercifulIbn ʿArabī · metaphysics
English throughout: AI translation of the Arabic AI
غ
Level of existence: الجسم الكل · the Universal Body
Divine Name: الظاهر · al-Ẓāhir, the Outward
Lunar mansion: الميسان وهي الهقعة · al-Maysān, which is al-Haqʿa
Futūḥāt ch. 198, line 62077Spheres of its simples (ch. 2): 9 line 2572 ↗
ي
Level of existence: السماء الأولى · The First Heaven
Divine Name: الرب · The Lord (al-Rabb)
Lunar mansion: الخرتان · al-Kharatān
Futūḥāt ch. 198, line 64500Spheres of its simples (ch. 2): 10 line 2573 ↗
Nature (ch. 2)
المرتبة العشرية فحروفها حارة يابسة
The tenfold rank: its letters are hot and dry.
Ibn ʿArabī, al-Futūḥāt al-Makkiyya, line 2582ر
Level of existence: السماء الخامسة · the fifth heaven
Divine Name: المصور · the Form-Giver (al-Muṣawwir)
Lunar mansion: الغفر · al-Ghafr
Futūḥāt ch. 198, line 64675Spheres of its simples (ch. 2): 10 line 2573 ↗
Nature (ch. 2)
المرتبة العشرية فحروفها حارة يابسة
The tenfold rank: its letters are hot and dry.
Ibn ʿArabī, al-Futūḥāt al-Makkiyya, line 2582Meaning by vowelal-Dabbāgh · a visionary claim about a primordial “Syriac”, not historical Syriac
English throughout: AI translation of the Arabic AI
غ
With fatḥa ـَ
فهي اسم للنظر الذي يبلغ به حقيقة الشيء.
It is a name for the gaze by which one reaches the reality of a thing.
With ḍamma ـُ
فهي اسم من أسمائه تعالى ويدل على الحنانة فيه.
It is one of the names of God (Exalted is He), and it denotes the tenderness in Him.
With kasra ـِ
فهي سؤال مما يجهله ليجيبه بما يعلمه.
It is a question, from one who does not know, so that someone may answer him with what he knows.
ي
With fatḥa ـَ
فهي للنداء، وقد يؤكد بها.
It is for the vocative (calling), and it may be used for emphasis.
With ḍamma ـُ
فهي إشارة إلى الشيء الذي لا يثبت كالبرق ونحوه.
It is an indication of the thing that does not remain fixed, like lightning and the like.
With kasra ـِ
فهي إشارة إلى الشيء الذي يستحيا به أو يستحيا منه كالعورة.
It is an indication of the thing that causes shame, or of which one is ashamed, like the private parts.
ر
With fatḥa ـَ
فهي إشارة إلى جميع الخيرات الظاهرة والباطنة.
It is an indication of all goods, outward and inward.
With ḍamma ـُ
فهي إشارة إلى الواحد في نفسه وهو ظاهر.
It is an indication of the one in itself, and it is manifest.
With kasra ـِ
فهي إشارة إلى الشيء الذي فيه الروح وليس من بني آدم، أو إشارة إلى الروح نفسها.
It is an indication of a thing that has spirit in it but is not of the children of Adam, or an indication of the spirit itself.
Two-letter nucleus5 roots in Ibn Fāris’s chapterغ ي
Ibn Fāris groups his roots under two-letter chapters (“the X and the Y and what makes them three”). These are the roots of this root's chapter with the core sense he gives each. Setting them side by side is our juxtaposition; he does not himself draw a shared meaning. His chapter heading, line 23871 ↗
- غيثالغين والياء والثاء أصل صحيح وهو الحيا النازل من السماءQ 4 · L23878
- غيرالغين والياء والراء أصلان صحيحان يدل أحدهما على صلاح وإصلاح ومنفعة والآخر على اختلاف شيئينQ 154 · L23881
- غيضالغين والياء والضاد أصيل يدل على نقصان في شيء وغموض وقلةQ 2 · L23897
- غيلالغين والياء واللام أصلان صحيحان أحدهما يدل على اجتماع والآخر نوع من الإرضاعL23908
- غينالغين والياء والنون قريب من الذي قبله فالغين الغيمL23918
In the sister scriptsHebrew ע י רSyriac ܥ ܝ ܪ
| Arabic | غ ي ر |
| Hebrew | ע י ר |
| Syriac | ܥ ܝ ܪ |
| Ancient South Arabian (musnad) | 𐩶 𐩺 𐩧 |
| Phoenician | 𐤏 𐤉 𐤓 |
Letter for letter, by the regular sound correspondences of the Semitic languages (Arabic keeps several sounds the others merged). This shows how the root would be spelled; whether a related word exists is a separate question, answered in the Semitic lens. Where an Arabic sibilant (s, sh) continues two older sounds, both spellings are shown.
Lenses
AIClassical lexiconNo excerpt from al-Khalīl was supplied.plausible
The lexicographers in chronological order, from al-Khalīl to Lane.
No excerpt from al-Khalīl was supplied. The Ṣiḥāḥ, Mufradāt and Lisān excerpts supplied here belong to the neighbouring root gh-w-r (depth, low ground, cave), so they are not used. For al-Jawharī we rely on Lane, who cites him: ghāra ahlahu, aorist yaghīru, verbal noun ghiyār, means 'he brought provisions (mīra) to his family' and 'he benefited them'. Ibn Fāris systematizes the root into two aṣls. The first is benefit and provisioning; he cites ghārahum Allāh bi-l-ghayth, 'God benefited them with rain', and assigns jealousy for one's household (ghayra) to this branch because it is a form of care. The second is 'this is ghayr that', meaning other than it and different from it, and it includes exceptive ghayr ('ten ghayr one') and Q 1:7. Lane keeps the provisioning sense first, glosses the Hudhalī verse as 'what will their weeping avail them', and cross-refers to art. غور, which reflects the overlap between the two roots in the lexica.
Draws on: Maqāyīs · Lane (citing Ṣiḥāḥ, Miṣbāḥ, TA) · source mismatch noted
- Ibn Fāris, Maqāyīs al-lugha, s.v. غير
- Lane, Arabic-English Lexicon, s.v. غار / غير
- Wiktionary: Arabic root غ ي ر ↗
Letters & soundIn Ibn ʿArabī's scheme of letters in the Breath of the All-Merciful, ghayn corresponds to the Universal Body, yāʾ to the First Heaven and rāʾ to the Fifth Heaven.speculative
What the theorists of sound symbolism would say of these letters. Speculative by nature.
In Ibn ʿArabī's scheme of letters in the Breath of the All-Merciful, ghayn corresponds to the Universal Body, yāʾ to the First Heaven and rāʾ to the Fifth Heaven. On that scheme the root would run from undifferentiated corporeality through two celestial levels. Al-Dabbāgh's meanings, as supplied, are these: ghayn is the gaze that reaches a thing's reality, yāʾ serves calling and emphasis, and rāʾ indicates all goods, outward and inward. One could set rāʾ beside Ibn Fāris's 'benefit' branch, and ghayn beside the discrimination implied by 'other'. The supplied material contains no specific imsās treatment of these letters by Ibn Jinnī. Mainstream linguistics treats such correspondences as suggestive at most.
Draws on: Ibn ʿArabī letter–cosmos correspondences (supplied) · al-Dabbāgh (supplied)
- Ibn ʿArabī, al-Futūḥāt al-Makkiyya, ch. 198 (letters and the Breath)
- Aḥmad b. al-Mubārak, al-Ibrīz (al-Dabbāgh on letters)
Root structureIbn Fāris's gh-y chapter places gh-y-r beside gh-y-th (rain from the sky), gh-y-ḍ (diminishing, sinking, obscurity), gh-y-l (gathering;speculative
The two-letter nucleus (Ibn Fāris's own chapters) and the permutations of the letters (Ibn Jinnī).
Ibn Fāris's gh-y chapter places gh-y-r beside gh-y-th (rain from the sky), gh-y-ḍ (diminishing, sinking, obscurity), gh-y-l (gathering; a kind of suckling) and gh-y-n (cloud, close in sense to the preceding). One link is internal to Ibn Fāris's own evidence: his example for the benefit sense of gh-y-r is benefit through rain (ghayth). Among the permutations, gh-r-y (admiration at something's beauty) and r-gh-y (something lying over something else; a sound) have entries in the Maqāyīs, and r-y-gh is marked attested without a definition. None of these permutations has a Quranic occurrence. No shared meaning across the permutations suggests itself, so Ibn Jinnī's greater derivation is not applied.
Draws on: Ibn Fāris chapter siblings · permutations
- Ibn Fāris, Maqāyīs al-lugha, bāb al-ghayn wa-l-yāʾ
- Ibn Jinnī, al-Khaṣāʾiṣ, bāb al-ishtiqāq al-akbar (link not verified)
Semitic kin & loanwordsNo secure cognate for gh-y-r, either as 'other' or as 'provision', can be given in Hebrew, Aramaic/Syriac, Akkadian, Geʿez or Epigraphic South Arabian.uncertain
Cognates in the sister languages, and whether the word was borrowed.
No secure cognate for gh-y-r, either as 'other' or as 'provision', can be given in Hebrew, Aramaic/Syriac, Akkadian, Geʿez or Epigraphic South Arabian. The root appears to be an Arabic development within Semitic, and the words for 'other' in those languages are built on different roots. There is no reason to regard ghayr as a loanword.
Draws on: no confident cognate
Quranic exegesisIn Q 1:7 the exegetes discuss the grammar of ghayr.plausible
How the classical exegetes read the word in the Quran.
In Q 1:7 the exegetes discuss the grammar of ghayr. It is read as a substitute (badal) for 'those whom You have favoured' or as its qualifier, and qualification is possible because the relative clause is not strictly definite. The minority accusative reading ghayra is taken as a circumstantial or exceptive construction. Al-Ṭabarī identifies 'those under wrath' and 'those astray' with the Jews and the Christians, following the ḥadīth of ʿAdī b. Ḥātim. In Q 2:59 ('they substituted a word other than what was said to them') he reports the tradition that ḥiṭṭa was mockingly replaced by ḥinṭa. For Q 4:119 ('they will alter God's creation'), al-Ṭabarī and al-Zamakhsharī record several views (castration, tattooing and similar bodily alterations, and alteration of God's religion or innate disposition); al-Ṭabarī favours 'religion'. Q 8:53 (compare 13:11) ties a change in God's favour to a people first changing 'what is in themselves', and al-Rāzī uses it to discuss causation and divine action. The lemma mughīrāt (Q 100:3), listed here, belongs lexically to gh-w-r (aghāra, to raid).
Philosophy & kalāmIn kalām, 'otherness' (ghayriyya) is a defined relation.plausible
The word as a technical term in falsafa and theology.
In kalām, 'otherness' (ghayriyya) is a defined relation. In the Ashʿarī tradition, two things are 'others' (ghayrān) when one can exist in the absence of the other. On that definition, the divine attributes are said to be 'neither He nor other than He' (lā huwa wa-lā ghayruhu), because they are inseparable from the essence and yet not identical with it. The Muʿtazila rejected this formula as a threat to divine unity. In Avicenna's metaphysics, 'the other' (al-ghayr) and difference belong with multiplicity, as the counterpart of identity (al-huwa huwa), which belongs with unity.
Draws on: Ashʿarī kalām · Avicenna
- H. A. Wolfson, The Philosophy of the Kalam (1976), on the attributes
- Avicenna, al-Shifāʾ: al-Ilāhiyyāt, on unity and multiplicity
Akbarian readingIn Faṣṣ Ādam, ghayr serves both as an ordinary particle and as a point of doctrine.plausible
The word in Ibn ʿArabī's text and terminology.
In Faṣṣ Ādam, ghayr serves both as an ordinary particle and as a point of doctrine. The Real's self-seeing in a form is given by the locus, and this form would not have appeared 'without the existence of this locus' (min ghayri wujūd). The world before Adam was 'like an unpolished mirror' (mirʾāt ghayr majluwwa). The angels are a warning: 'God has admonished you by another (bi-ghayrika)'. Most significant is the claim about the universals (al-umūr al-kulliyya): they govern everything that has concrete existence, and each 'is their very identity, not other than them' (ʿaynuhā lā ghayruhā). This denial of otherness, an identity-in-difference between the intelligible and its instances, anticipates the wider Akbarian treatment of the relation between the Real and the world. No Iṣṭilāḥ definition of ghayr is supplied.
Draws on: Faṣṣ Ādam contexts (supplied)
- Ibn ʿArabī, Fuṣūṣ al-ḥikam, Faṣṣ Ādam
Reference